South Carolina Went to Times Square and Came Back With Impressions
The state took nearly $1.5 million to Manhattan, put its name on seven billboards and came home with 16.2 million impressions. Now the incoming comptroller wants to see the bill.

The great thing about an impression is that it doesn’t have to do a damn thing. It doesn’t have to pull off I-95, spend a night in Florence or buy a plate of shrimp anywhere in the state of South Carolina. It can occur in Times Square while a man from New Jersey is looking down at his phone, trying to figure out why his train has stopped running. He can go home, forget the whole miserable afternoon and still be part of a success story in Columbia.
This is the number we keep coming back to in the South Carolina Department of Parks, Recreation and Tourism’s account of its September trip to Manhattan. Sixteen point two million impressions. We wanted to know how many people came to South Carolina because of it. So did Mike Burkhold, the man South Carolina just elected to be comptroller general. The department’s preliminary figures give us plenty to look at while we wait. The website was up 84 percent. There were more than 20,000 consumer interactions. The whole affair cost just under $1.5 million, supplied by the General Assembly. Burkhold’s breakdown of the preliminary figures · WSPA’s reporting on the campaign
There was also dinner.
A table in Manhattan
On the evening side of “SC in the City,” James London of Charleston’s Chubby Fish and Joe Cash of Greenville’s Scoundrel joined Daniel Humm’s team at Eleven Madison Park for a one-night menu built around South Carolina ingredients. We can think of worse ways to spend a night in Manhattan. We can think of cheaper ones, too, although here we run into the first real problem. The reporting confirms the dinner took place. The check, the name on the check and the names of the people who sat down remain unanswered. The Post and Courier’s account of the dinner

Burkhold wrote on X that the agency’s plan called the dinner “The South Carolina Table at Eleven Madison Park” and listed media, influencers, business leaders and legislators as intended guests. Intended guests are an interesting species. They can take up a whole page in a planning document without ever occupying a chair. The people doing their own digging on South Carolina’s corner of X ought to be able to see who actually showed up, along with the itemized dinner bill and who paid it. “It’s the taxpayers’ money. Every dollar needs to be treated with respect,” Burkhold wrote. Burkhold’s post on X
For a sense of how this sounds in the state that sent the money, consider Claflin University’s October poll. Asked what mattered most in their vote for governor, 56.7 percent of registered South Carolina voters surveyed chose cost of living and inflation. At the grocery store, nobody hands us a slide deck to explain what a dozen eggs costs. We can see what we paid for and what we got. We’d settle for that level of sophistication from Columbia. Claflin University’s October poll
“When families are having to pick between paying for gas or groceries, taking their money and throwing a lavish party at one of the coolest restaurants in America isn’t exactly a good look. You don’t have to be a political genius to see how dumb this was,” said Wesley Donehue, the publisher of The Stack and a South Carolina-based political consultant.
The people who made the hype reel
PRT’s advertising agency of record is 9Rooftops. We wanted to see that name on an invoice. The department says it buys media through the firm. 9Rooftops put a hype video on its own LinkedIn page and credited itself with helping bring the Grand Central event to life. The firm called it “one for the books.” PRT’s advertising program · 9Rooftops’ LinkedIn video

The only thing dumber than throwing this event was posting a hype video of people popping champagne and eating in one of Manhattan’s most celebrated dining rooms. And what a restaurant. Eleven Madison Park is the name Richie throws at Carmy in the pilot of The Bear when he wants to call him a fancy-restaurant asshole. In South Carolina tourism marketing, that same name goes on the invitation. Untapped New York on Eleven Madison Park’s connection to The Bear
Fine. Open the books. What did 9Rooftops pitch? Pull the deck from before the trip, when somebody still had to make the case for spending the money. How much did the firm collect? Break out the media buy, the production costs, the agency fee and the vendors. What did the firm say would happen after the billboards went dark? If the pitch had a goal for bookings or visitor spending, we can put it beside the results. If the pitch was seven screens in Times Square and a great little video for LinkedIn, then by God somebody got exactly what they paid for. We’d like to know whether that somebody was South Carolina.
The firm’s post establishes that it worked on the Grand Central event. Its fee and any role in the Eleven Madison Park dinner are still unclear. Burkhold told FITSNews his transition team was preparing to ask for invoices, procurement records, guest lists and itemized hospitality bills. That paperwork could tell us who pitched which part of the trip, who signed off and whether the checks matched the work. There’s a perfectly ordinary way to settle this. It involves giving the public a stack of boring documents. FITSNews’ interview with Burkhold
The man on the 5:42
PRT had a reason to pick New York. Its leisure marketing manager, Devyn Whitmire, told WSPA that Grand Central sees roughly 750,000 people a day. PRT Director Duane Parrish told the Post and Courier the United Nations General Assembly was in town, putting potential international visitors within reach. There’s a case for putting a destination in front of people who might actually go there. Good. Let’s see how the department planned to find out what happened next. WSPA’s interview with Whitmire · The Post and Courier’s interview with Parrish
In his Show Me the Money video, Burkhold divides the full campaign cost by the roughly 20,000 reported interactions. He gets about $75 apiece. That might be a bargain if the person across the table is about to bring six relatives to South Carolina for a week. Imagine, instead, a man hustling for the 5:42 who takes a free sample and eats it before he gets to the platform. Delicious. Possibly the best thing that happened to him all day. Does he go in the same column? The state’s top-line numbers leave us guessing. Watch Burkhold’s video
Dorchester County Sen. Sean Bennett gets at the same thing in his No Ease In Liberty video. He makes the case for tourism spending before asking who picked Times Square, what research backed it and how the department will know if the people who saw it ever show up. Bennett is in the legislature. If he wants to see the math, imagine being the taxpayer trying to find it between shifts. Watch Bennett’s video
Back in Columbia
Nikki Haley put Parrish in the job in January 2011. He stayed through Henry McMaster’s administration and told the SC Daily Gazette he’ll apply to stay under Alan Wilson. The governor-elect gave Cabinet directors until Dec. 4 to tell him whether they want to keep serving. Wilson said he’ll consider new people for every Cabinet agency. There’s no public indication this trip will decide Parrish’s fate. The timing does make for a hell of a job interview. Parrish’s state biography · SC Daily Gazette’s reporting on the Cabinet
We’d ask Parrish two questions in that interview. How many extra visitors did PRT expect this campaign to bring to South Carolina? How many can it show actually came? If the results are still coming in, tell us when we’ll see them.
In the meantime, release the itemized invoices. We want to know what 9Rooftops was paid, what the dinner cost and who picked up the tab.
Disclosure: The Stack is published by Wesley Donehue, whose firm works for Comptroller General-elect Mike Burkhold and Sen. Sean Bennett.
Where this comes from
- Burkhold’s breakdown of the preliminary figures
- WSPA’s reporting on the campaign
- The Post and Courier’s account of the dinner
- Burkhold’s post on X
- Claflin University’s October poll
- PRT’s advertising program
- 9Rooftops’ LinkedIn video
- Untapped New York on Eleven Madison Park’s connection to *The Bear*
- FITSNews’ interview with Burkhold
- Watch Burkhold’s video
- Watch Bennett’s video
- Parrish’s state biography
- SC Daily Gazette’s reporting on the Cabinet
See something we got wrong? Email news@thestacksc.com and we'll fix it and note the correction here.